Marhofn 269.15 - May 2013

Previous | Contents | Next

Sims, Subs and Surveys

Alan Dawson

In 2012 I surprised myself by splashing out on a second-hand Leica 1250 GPS system, which enables me to emulate some of the activities of the tamperers. I do not have a level and staff, or the same levels of patience and dedication, or a faithful border tamperer to carry equipment and film the proceedings. Nor do I have the expensive software to process the raw survey data. Scoop John B kindly offered to run the software if I supplied him with the data, which produces highly accurate measurements but has the disadvantage that I have to wait a while after the survey to find out the results, which diminishes the excitement somewhat.

Results of the hill surveys I carried out last year are summarised below, with the focus on marginal Sims and Submarilyns, plus the occasional Subhump, all in Scotland. Without the equipment or expertise of the tamperers, I tried a more lightweight one-man operation. This meant that I could not always identify the precise position of a col (and sometimes a summit) to set up the GPS and collect the satellite data. I tried to compensate for this by carrying out a survey in two, or occasionally three, different nearby locations, so that I could be reasonably confident that one of them was the actual col (or summit).

This meant shorter survey times, of 30-90 minutes, rather than the two hours or more commonly used by the tamperers and required for Ordnance Survey validation. I was more concerned with fitting the surveys into bagging trips than with external validation, so on some occasions I was able to leave the equipment at a col to go and bag a summit, though this did not work very well if I wanted to survey the summit too. These methods mean there is a slightly greater margin for error than in surveys by the tamperers, so I only quote figures to the nearest 10cm. Even this is far more accurate than any data from large-scale maps or any other source.

The most difficult hills to survey were Aonach Beag, where both summit and col were under several inches of snow, Leum Uilleim, where the enormous cairn made it difficult to locate the highest natural ground (it turned out to be a small rock 20 metres west of the cairn), and Marg na Craige, where the sprawling col made it almost impossible to locate the right survey point with any certainty, so the margin for error was a relatively huge 0.5m. However, even this was enough to confirm that the drop is very unlikely to be as much as 150m.

My overall response to these surveys was a mixture of disappointment and satisfaction. It was disappointing that none of the Submarilyns were promoted, and only one Subsim (Meall Reamhar North Top, formerly Creag Mac Ranaich point 616m), yet satisfying that my original findings derived from maps turned out to be remarkably accurate in most cases.

One survey produced unreliable results which were discarded owing to equipment malfunction (the pole blew over in the high wind while I was away on a route recce). The Cairnie Hill col was also very difficult to survey with my methods, the col being alongside the railway line with thick tree cover either side of the track. This hill was also surveyed by the tamperers at the same time, who were able to set up their GPS in a clearer location and use levelling to work out the actual col height. In fact there was very close correlation between the two sets of measurements at both summit and col, which was reassuring, but it did confirm that it would not be possible for me to survey tree-covered summits or cols with my current methods. However, this still leaves plenty of hills on my hit list, so I hope to carry out more surveys in 2013. Results will be summarised at as well as in Marhofn in due course.

As well as the survey results reported here and by John Barnard, some further changes derived from extensive study of large-scale online maps by the Hills Database team, particularly Jim Bloomer, which have led to one new Submarilyn and one more new Sim:

10A Sgurr Mor Far West Top600 c35 NG869082 New Sim
28B Moneylaws Hill246140 NT872347 New Submarilyn

With the addition of Meall Reamhar North Top but the demotion of Meallan Liath, this takes the current number of Sims up to 2532. The Sim Hall of Fame continues to stay out of reach of most baggers, with just two new entrants during 2012, leaving the table looking like this:

Ken Whyte2532
Iain Thow2389
Colin Crawford2288
Andy Hyams2195
Rob Woodall2021

I hope to join them in two or three year's time, fitness and will permitting.

Section Hill Height Drop Grid reference Outcome
1B Beinn Each North Top704.027.4 NN601163 Confirmed as Subsim, drop less than 30m
1C Am Fireach712.930.7 NN561125 Confirmed as Sim, drop over 30m
1C Meall Reamhar670.599.2 NN569247 Confirmed as Subhump
1C Meall Reamhar North Top619.231.8 NN562257 New Sim, drop increased from 28m
4A Leum Uilleim906.4497 NN331641 Height measured, 909m on maps refers to cairn
4A Leum Uilleim South Top847.232.5 NN332633 Confirmed as Sim, drop over 30m
4B Aonach Beag1115.799.0 NN458742 Confirmed as Subhump and not a New Munro
4B Beinn Eibhinn1103.2127 NN450733 East top is summit, at NN 44965 73302
4B Beinn a'Chumhainn901.9145.4 NN463710 Confirmed as Submarilyn and New Munro
4B Meall a'Bhealaich865.297.4 NN452695 Confirmed as Subhump
4B Meall na Duibhe571.3149.1 NN227623 Confirmed as Submarilyn
9B Marg na Craige833.5149.1 NN621973 Confirmed as Submarilyn
9B Beinn a'Chrasgain826.662 NN606981 Confirmed as lower than Marg na Craige
16B Meallan Liath599.7147.4 NC515504 Confirmed as Submarilyn, deleted Sim
16B Ben Screavie333.0145.8 NC309394 Confirmed as Submarilyn
16E Sail na Slataich652.129.8 NC314305 Confirmed as Subsim, drop less than 30m
16E Spidean Coinich East Top620.729.4 NC211273 Confirmed as Subsim, drop less than 30m
26 Cairnie Hill228.8150.3 NO279159 Confirmed as Marilyn
28B Middle Hill717.142 NT159295 Height and drop confirmed
28B Grey Weather Law712.025 NT169301 Confirmed as Subsim, col location moved
28B Taberon Law636.728.6 NT146289 Confirmed as Subsim, drop less than 30m
28B Fastheugh Hill501.5144.9 NT393276 Confirmed as Submarilyn

The In Sim?

This tricky boulder stands about 2.5m high on top of a summit that may or may not be a new Sim. It's listed in the Hills Database as 601m high, drop 27m, but that does not include the boulder. After four failures I finally managed to slither up it from the other side (which is easier) by taking off my boots and getting a grip with my socks, so it would be not be easy to get a GPS up there and balance it on the top. I may need help to survey this one. The hills shown to the north are the Beinn a'Ghlo group, and you may need a G'n'T to help you up it.

Previous | Contents | Next